Theoretically the German id card at least is capable of providing just the age and just that in an easy to control and secure fashion over NFC.
In practice there is exactly one shitty smartphone app available to interact with other shitty smartphone apps to give them absolutely everything available on the card.
Yeah, this is what governments keep saying to critics: “We’re only reading the age, no other info. Don’t worry about it. We will definitely 100% not read any other info”
This is treating Twitter as a pornographic website, which the new French law puts more requirements on. If it was just a “I am over 18” button, I don’t think pornhub would pull out(pun unintended). It’s easy to bypass with a VPN or tor, but are you going to pull that out just to doom scroll for a hate fix? Maybe, but that’s a choice a lot of people are going to have to make.
I’m all for making it exceedingly less convenient for people become radicalized, personally. Age verification isn’t a magic bullet, but still very much worth doing.
“France considers requiring Musk’s X to get users to lie about their age”
FTFY
The EU is planning on introducing mandatory e-identification for everything online (1). This is just laying the foundations (for the children!!!)
Theoretically the German id card at least is capable of providing just the age and just that in an easy to control and secure fashion over NFC.
In practice there is exactly one shitty smartphone app available to interact with other shitty smartphone apps to give them absolutely everything available on the card.
And it doesn’t even work.
Yeah, this is what governments keep saying to critics: “We’re only reading the age, no other info. Don’t worry about it. We will definitely 100% not read any other info”
This is treating Twitter as a pornographic website, which the new French law puts more requirements on. If it was just a “I am over 18” button, I don’t think pornhub would pull out(pun unintended). It’s easy to bypass with a VPN or tor, but are you going to pull that out just to doom scroll for a hate fix? Maybe, but that’s a choice a lot of people are going to have to make.
I’m all for making it exceedingly less convenient for people become radicalized, personally. Age verification isn’t a magic bullet, but still very much worth doing.
What you’re saying is that the government should control access to information, so that people will hold the correct ideology.
I don’t think that’s a game that a liberal democracy can win.
Nice straw man.
Additionally it’s convenient tooling to have in place for other undesirable behaviour, as our EU overlords are getting Orbanised.