he/him

Alts (mostly for modding)

@sga013@lemmy.world

(Earlier also had @sga@lemmy.world for a year before I switched to @sga@lemmings.world, now trying piefed)

  • 16 Posts
  • 24 Comments
Joined 8 months ago
cake
Cake day: March 14th, 2025

help-circle


  • sga@piefed.socialtoOnePiece@lemmy.worldOne Piece Chapter 1165
    link
    fedilink
    English
    arrow-up
    3
    ·
    edit-2
    9 days ago

    After having seen the chapter, my anger (see my comment on brief spoiler post) has cooled down a bit, because the frames look really good. Also, seeing the dialogue with frames, the back and forth between garp and roger, how they are emotional is special too. I wanted the fight to last longer, but another truth is, I don’t want any of them to take more beating.

    A goat has been downed, and 2 more are crowned.

    Also for people who constantly keep asking why garp has not left the marines - listen directly from the goat’s mouth - “If I leave, who is gonna save the marines”

    Interesting point left out by spoilers is that rayleigh and gaban went back to the island (seemingly towards roger, and they would be the ones who would seemingly get roger and garp out, as they would also be knocked out for exerting all their haki).


  • My thoughts

    I am disappointed. And I am one of those people who watches/reads one piece for the lore and not the fights. But for the biggest fight the story was kinda leading for hundreds of chapter culminating in just 1 chapter, or even half is disappointing. I think it is one part because none them are fruit users, so creativity wise you do not have much going and fight is effectively a haki measuring contest, and I am kinda sad that it got solved in a chapter. like seriously we could not do 2 chapters, when wano lasted 150, 90 chapters for effectively 1 single night, and the fight that made gapr and roger who they are is just 1 chapter. Are you swears kidding me. I am a big Oda (Goda) fan, but this is disappoitning. In reddit comments people said “oda left it all to toei”, or “oda did all his action in luffy vs kaido and doess not want to do anymore” but like seriously?

    How fast it ended kinda ended has kinda made me believe that they are adapting it for a movie and maybe someone from the production side has maybe given directions that they should not make manga reveal all the fight. I know I am being consipartorial (my first time for OP), but there does not seem any other way. I know from reading ~1200 chapters, Oda is not masterful at drawing fights, lots of people complain too. The sword fights lack, and the best are fruit fisghts. but luffy vs kaido was fun. Even in egghead, luffy vs kizaru was longer. Oda is not in a time crunch to finish manga soon.

    Someone said that in flashbacks fights have always been short, but that is kinda not correct imo, because I do not remember any other big fight in flash back. only kinda fights in flashback are either just plot device, like oden and kaido fought, but since oden’s family was kidnapped, he gave up. There is akainu vs ice admiral (i am having a brain freeze and can’t remeber his name)(no pun intended), but we atleast got the fact that fight lasted 10 whole days (for those who have fought irl may know real life fights 1v1 lasting 10 minutes is large), and a island was devasted in fight, and maybe with actual chapter we will see more destruction, but right now this is not looking even as good. I can not think of any other major fights in flash back.

    Regardless, this was “the fight” alluded for hundreds of chapters, this hould not follow any trends, it should be the exception.

    Other things are as expected from the chapter. Dragon finally had a revolutionary moment. I kinda like “Marco Polo” bit (that would be his full name in english). But the fight has made me really sad.



  • my thoughts -

    I had heard the franky theory. I do not know what to say about it other than - NEPO PIECE IS REAL!

    I did not catch the future vivi design in first glance, and comment chain in linked thread put into my notice that vivi is a CD in it. While oda previously has drawn bizzare future version, I do not remember him writing “if something happens”. my guess is that that future is the one where luffy loses, and imu wins and since imu has interest in viv/lily. Some more fans to that flame i guess.

    jinbei question caught me offguard ngl.

    SAINT ROSWARD ROSWARD is a very interesting thing. for those who may not know, there are many theories for what the D stands for, and one of them is that it stands for Davy. It’s audience got split when we learnt that xebec is Davy and goes by Davy D Xebec. Either it stands for something else (dawn/dusk/devil being other major candidates) or that it stands for Davy only (as in Davy Davy Xebec).

    There are some other things hinting it for davy davy, like tony tony chopper, all fruits following the repition scheme as well.

    So considireing this, either Oda is calling all people rooting for davy davy stupid, or he is hinting that the possibilty is still there (as in, in the world, repition is accpted). Either way, goda is playing us all fools, as is epected by goda.





  • They all know about domi reversi and it seems they know a way to resist it, but Xebec wasn’t ready for it.

    I do not think so. xebec’s family (percievably) did not resist it. my guess is it depends on how strong your will (haki) is. seemingly only xebec is the one who could even resist.

    All D. are Davy’s descendant ?

    (most of these are community beliefs). No, current idea is basically D are all families (monkey, trafalgar, nefertari, etc) who were with davy/joyboy in the lost century.

    Is it the haki from roger that IMU confuses for Davy’s ? Or is it the power Xebec uses to appear before him ?

    I am not sure what part/page you are refering to. roger (and garp) was basically non present in this chapter except for last 2 pages.

    Damn, I never hoped god valley would be this intense. I feared it would be a letdown, but… Damn !!!

    I never expected it to be a letdown. but i certainly did not expect to get GV so soon or so good. i expected it to be on par with or slightly succeed marineford. currently, (imo), we are even past that.






  • my thoughts

    As always, oda has cooked very hard.

    Kuma is the goat. he was very nearto being my most favorite OP character (touch challenge between garp luff and him) but after god valley, he is now my favorite (even my profile pick is now kuma).

    Oda absolutely killed with rocks. I cried IRL seeing rocks cry. this has hinted towards the fact that while reversed, they retain some bit of conscience. maybe it is just because rocks is strong to resist, but seeing him cry, it gave a whole new dimension to our understanding of god valley.

    Most of community guessed it already that rocks would be reversed and seeing how much carnage he is causing, garp and roger will decide to take him down. None of us could guess that rocks was essentially asking a mercy killing. rather than being a puppet to imu, he would prefer death. maybe he was also crying because he attacked his own wife and child. it broke him (and me irl).

    I never would have guessed it, but rocks is now in my top 5 favorite characters in OP.



  • they are federated just as piefed is, but the difference is that in lemmy/piefed, you do not want to follow particular users, you follow communities. on peertube, you follow users. so when you watch a video on one instance, you can watch a video from different instance too, its just that peertube does not have a great recommendation algorithm. in lemmy/piefed, when you go to home page, and just search something, content from all comunities is shown. in earlier versions of peertube, you could not search across instances. now you can. if you want a better search, try - https://sepiasearch.org/



  • is the spoiler bit that they are going to elbaph?

    i do not know how to put title to spoiler.

    imo, anything which is put in OP social media is not a spoiler for a one piece sub.

    I understand anime is behind, but this may require more community discussion.

    for now, i am editting the title to - next arc official designs, but this seems a bit odd