many channels pretend to be human-made, but are just AI slop.
I’ll wait for mobile support
I like that it isn’t just a binary “yes/no”. IMCO there’s a big difference between using AI to generate a few assets/b-roll, and entirely automated video pipelines.
It struck me how seamlessly AI can now mimic human creativity, to the point where it’s nearly impossible to distinguish between human-made and AI-generated content.
And let any non trained people to subjectively judge if the content is AI generated? With the latest versions of video generation models we are already in the situation where only software can tell if some videos are AI generated or not. Lots of channels will be wrongly tagged.
Fair enough. Though I don’t know about your point regarding the software tools. The ones I tried had pretty bad accuracy (and were quite resource-intensive to run) So, I felt like the human-tagging way was still the most sensible way forward. At least for now, where there are still subtle cues that give AI-content away once in a while.
Adding a link to such a tool with “If you are unsure you can use xyz. Note that these are often inaccurate” would be enough to address this.
I think it’s a pretty good idea. I personally don’t have an issue seeing if it’s AI slop as for me, they seem to be still very obvious with cuts not making sense, the generic male or female voice or even script errors. However, I can see it for channels that are using it more in a hidden manner like JCS’ video “Newlyweds Tell on Each Other”, which has since been deleted because of the backlash.
What was the story with the JCS video?
It’s been hard to find good websites in top results of search engines. A lot of them are very well SEO tuned AI slop.
Especially on Duck Duck Go. Ugh. It’s so bad sometimes. You search for a topic and the first page is all blog style websites with rambling, garbage A.I. text.
I really need to switch to Kagi, but it’s American so I don’t want to give them money.
Kagi is just a mix of Bing, Google, Yandex, Mojeek, Brave with AI and it’s not worth for $10
it’s not worth for $10
I subscribed to the $5 plan last night for that very reason, and then immediately unsubscribed because it was the most user-hostile search engine I’ve ever used. Limit of 300 searches per month, with the 300 AI interactions that I’ll never use being a separate category. There’s also a cap of 1000 sites in the personalized results. Worst all all though the theme made my eyes bleed and every time I refreshed the page trying to get it to apply the custom CSS it ran up my 300 searches. Oh and also they only show you a maximum of two pages of results FFS. Bloody hell the issues are endless.
I just wanted the ability to uprank good sites, and downrank or block a handful. Being able to brand domains as trusted is the best solution I can think of to AI polluting search results.
DuckDuckGo allows me to block 5 sites and sync that between browsers but not uprank or downrank them.
Brave allows me to uprank and block, but not downrank or sync between devices. And it doesn’t let me uprank the au TLD (which is far more restrictive than com or org). Also after upranking anime-planet.com and searching for “The Apothecary Diaries” it didn’t show up in the results at all unless I appended “site:anime-planet.com”.
For me the dealbreaker was they don’t care user requests (they have a platform kagifeedback.org for listenining users, just listening not caring!) and they don’t do any real improvements for search quality
here is a good critisizm https://マリウス.com/doubting-your-favorite-web-search-engine/
yeah what if I just want “Search Engine”
For me the specific dealbreaker is the price. Specifically because it’s not the price of a artisanal search engine, it’s the price of an AI chatbot (both in terms of the dollar value and what they’re spending it on).
And now, to read that site’s article on javascript and see if I need to rethink whether disabling Wasm and WebGL by default is enough (Edit: That article is just a list of vulnerabilities and a guide on how to disable javascript).
Mojeek and Ecosia are building their own index, and then you don’t need to subscribe to a service that’s all-in on AI
Every time I try mojeek it’s the worse experience ever. Ask Jeeves was more reliable.
Never heard of exosia tho have to try it.
I’m sorry to disappoint you further, but Ecosia, like DDG, is just A Bing proxy for now.
Regardless, I support their effort to break the US stranglehold on search engines
I’m not really against AI (specifically text-based GenAI), but AI does change the reality of using the internet. I need to be able to promote trustworthy domains in my search results and accumulate such a list over years.
Brave search technically has such a feature, but firstly the owner is a homophobe, and secondly the feature isn’t really as power-user oriented as I’d like.
We really need something like this, maybe an addon or userscript
