Great piece and I don’t really have anything to add. But I’m glad that there exists people who recognize the problem with AI is the capitalist system it exist within, not the tool itself.

It’s important to make a distinction between the definition of “open source AI” canonized by the OSI that doesn’t require open training data, and models where all of the training data used is also made available.

Separately, the tools most people think about when they hear “AI”, generalized generative AI models, only exist as capitalist surplus, and we shouldn’t be defending them. Hyper focused AI tools such as the Te Hiku Media project to create speech recognition tools for the te reo Māori language are unequivocally good, and we should be making a lot more projects like this.