

I think it has less to do with appearances than the popularity of issues/people they choose to pursue with their actions.
Luigi off’ed someone pretty much universally reviled across political spectrums. Probably a good 80% of people could sympathize at least a little with what Luigi did. Every adult has probably had extensive personal experience dealing with the dysfunction of our healthcare system. Brian Thompson is just the personification of that.
Tyler did a perfect one-shot with the most hilarious timing on someone that was loathed by ~50% of the country and liked by the other ~50%.
The two issues have a fairly wide gap in universal appeal.









Oof, the projection is strong with this one 🤭