If science is defined as some kind of systematic study of observed experience applied to hypotheses or theories, and then confirmation or refutation of those hypotheses or theories, followed by new hypotheses or theories that are further tested and refined by new observations – if this is the core of any scientific inquiry, I think that no objective observer can attribute the history of DSM-III, IV, and 5 to anything that approximates this process.

None of the DSM editions had ever been scientific lmao.

“our understanding of the biology of mental disorders has been slow in coming.”

There’s no biology in mental disorders; none of them have objective phenomena and they are arbitrarily given and created.

  • AmiceseOP
    -1•2 years ago

    But no one’s saying that people suffering from anxiety disorder happen to be going through those experiences through psychiatrists,

    They are; that doesn’t make Anxiety Disorders scientific; and the lack of mention of such situation is independent of its possibility.

    that’s completely irrelevant.

    It is relevant.

    The physical experiences come alongside an Anxiety’s phenomenon, and so do dissociative experiences due to anxiety itself.

    I’m referring to Anxiety Disorder, not the Anxiety of emotion, don’t equivocate the two.

    • @altair222@beehaw.org
      3•2 years ago

      How would you define anxiety of emotion, and differentiate it or disassociate it from anxiety disorder?

      • AmiceseOP
        -1•2 years ago

        Anxiety, as an emotion, is a feeling of unease, such as worry or fear, that can be mild or severe. It is generated as a reaction to stress.

        Anxiety disorders are “mental disorders” characterized by symptoms of intense anxiety or panic.

        • @altair222@beehaw.org
          3•2 years ago

          And what’s the issue with those characterisations? Given that the symptoms of intense anxiety or panic in themselves ought to have biological phenomenon behind them if we’re going by a physicalist-realism perspective of the human mind and body?

          • AmiceseOP
            -1•2 years ago

            And what’s the issue with those characterisations

            Nothing. The problem is that anxiety disorders are subjectively given and do not have falsifiable phenomena.

            They are also very reductionist; anxiety is an important emotion and it is very rational to be anxious when dealing with uncertain issues (like getting food poisoning). Anxiety helps to motivate to take action.

            Given that the symptoms of intense anxiety or panic in themselves ought to have biological phenomenon behind them

            Ought to have is not the same as proven to have (through disproving a null hypothesis); and anxiety disorders are not based on scientific research; but instead assertions.

            if we’re going by a physicalist-realism perspective of the human mind and body?

            what’s physical-realism?