Yet another refugee who washed up on the shore after the great Reddit disaster of 2023

  • 18 Posts
  • 263 Comments
Joined 2 years ago
cake
Cake day: June 12th, 2023

help-circle








  • If you end up searching online for that kind of things, “hard science fiction” is the phrase that’s usually used for it.

    A lot of good recommendations here. Some endorsements and other recommendations:

    • Project Hail Mary by Weir is a no brainer choice if you liked The Marian. He gets the science right.
    • Children of Time, by Adrian Tchaikovsky is amazing, and the first of a trilogy, so more to read.
    • The whole Expanse series, by James Corey is good and he does a good job with the science, especially the celestial mechanics.
    • The Uplift series (starting with Sundiver) by David Brin is great, and Brin is will known for hard SF. It’s from the 80s.
    • Ancillary Justice, by Ann Leckie, is great and the first of a series as well.
    • Beggars in Spain, by Nancy Kress, is great, with a good science background, though it’s more genetics than engineering. Really cool story though.
    • I also agree with the recommendation on Saturn’s Children, by Charles Stross. Also the first of a loose series.

    On the flip side, I really didn’t care for Three Body Problem, and though the Bobiverse books seem fun, I’m not sure I’d call them firmly hard SF.







  • Okay, I finished We Are Legion (Bobiverse book one). It was fun, and I’ll probably read the next. Nothing especially deep, but amusing. A few things bugged me a little:

    Minor spoilers
    • They spent all that time and energy trying to figure out how to feed the people on earth while they built ships, then put them in stasis for a multi-year trip. Why didn’t they start by building the stasis chambers and not having to worry about feeding them?
    • He has a rationale for life in the galaxy being compatible with earth life, but it doesn’t explain why the animals are so similar (e.g., birds with feathers). That’s not super unusual, but it seemed odd that the first intelligent beings they found were psychologically so human. Strains credibility.
    • I liked all the different story threads as we follow the different Bobs, but the sacrifice was that we didn’t go very deep into any of them and the ending felt kind of abrupt.

  • Several people have mentioned budgetary restrictions, which is a huge part, but there are practical considerations, regardless of budget. Even with a big budget, it’s only recently that they’ve been able to make convincing non-humanoid aliens that interact with other actors (mostly through CGI). Earlier, there were good examples of movie monsters or aliens that were done with stop motion or puppets, but not in a way that they shared the screen with the human actors in a meaningful way. Can you imagine if, say, the Vulcans on the original Trek series were wildly non-human - how silly it would have looked? The technology just wasn’t there to pull it off.

    Also, most aliens, even in books, are some variation of earth life. They’re reptile-people, big spiders, intelligent bugs, or whatever. I think that’s mostly because it’s pretty hard to envision something truly novel/new. So lots of books, movies, and shows come up with some rationale for why everything in the galaxy looks like some kind of earth life to excuse that.