• 0 Posts
  • 30 Comments
Joined 1 year ago
cake
Cake day: June 21st, 2023

help-circle

  • I went on a “tangent” rather than answering your question, because I don’t agree with the underlying assumption.

    You asked if it was speciesist to prefer one species over another. By definition it is, thats just what speciesism is defined as. I have an issue with the underlying assumption that speciesism is

    a) bad

    and

    b) the same as racism

    I could’ve just said: “yes, that is indeed speciesist”, but that wouldn’t have gotten my point across.

    Your last paragraph hosently doesn’t have anything to do with anything I said. I don’t care about morals, but I believe one shouldn’t cause any more suffering than necessary, that goes for humans and animals.


  • The point is though, treating them all equally doesn’t make any sense because based on their species they have different needs.

    Some animals enjoy the company of humans, others do not. Some radiate a calmness that is appealing to some, while others have an enthusiasm that more fits other personalities. So when getting a pet, why would you ignore all that?

    Should I get a crocodile as a pet just to treat them all the same? I wouldn’t be doing that crocodile any favour, nor myself.

    I guess its that old “equality vs equity” debate all over again.




  • You can call it speciesism if you want, but fish are just not quite as cuddly as cats. So if you like a pet thats cuddly, you will prefer cats over fish and admitting that is in no way problematic.

    Equating speciesism with racism also doesn’t make a lot of sense to me. Species do exist in nature, they are hard boundaries which animals can breed. Races on the other hand are a made-up concept with no biological basis, used to distinguish between similar-looking groups within a species.

    A fish and a cat cannot breed, as they are different species. A british shorthair and a sphynx on the other hand can, as the distinction is entirely artificial.

    Racism is the wrong belief that races, like species are a biological concept that can be found in nature.

    Speciesism differs from that, because different species do exist. For any two individual animals you can always determine if they belong to the same species, which isn’t true for races. Animals of the same species do share traits, while there are differences between animals of different species.

    In my opinion, pretending that every living being is the same would be way more problematic than what you call speciesism.











  • Lemvi@lemmy.sdf.orgtoShowerthoughts@lemmy.worldDresden
    link
    fedilink
    arrow-up
    2
    arrow-down
    1
    ·
    edit-2
    1 year ago

    The AfD is currently getting 35% in surveys in saxony, meaning the majority of people does not support the AfD.

    I’d even argue that right wing parties are way bigger in Poland (PiS and Konfederacja) than they are in Saxony or Dresden. So if Dresden is too right-leaning for you, the same should probably be true for Poland.